The Legal and Economic Implications of the Five Largest Mergers and Acquisitions of 2024-25

The global mergers and acquisitions (M&A) landscape experienced a resurgence in 2024, increasing by approximately 15% from the previous year and ultimately reaching an estimated $3.45 trillion. This rise in M&A activity was driven by technological advancements, corporate consolidation efforts, and market positioning strategies. The legal outcomes of these deals significantly impacted the shaping of regulatory oversight, antitrust deliberations, and shareholder impact. This article explores the five most significant M&A transactions of 2024 and their broader legal and economic implications.

ExxonMobil's Acquisition of Pioneer Natural Resources ($64.5 Billion)

In May 2024, ExxonMobil announced its $64.5 billion acquisition of Pioneer Natural Resources, positioning itself as the dominant force in the Permian Basin. The deal, an all-stock transaction that included the assumption of $5.5 billion in debt, was structured to increase ExxonMobil’s production efficiency and competitiveness in the shale oil sector.

From a legal standpoint, this acquisition attracted scrutiny from U.S. and international regulatory bodies, particularly under antitrust and environmental law frameworks. Given ExxonMobil’s strengthened control over key domestic oil reserves, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) examined potential risks of monopolization within the energy sector. Environmental organizations also raised concerns regarding compliance with sustainability commitments and emission reduction policies. The acquisition underscored the tension between corporate growth and regulatory oversight in the energy industry.

Mars’s Purchase of Kellanova ($35.9 Billion)

Mars Incorporated, a global leader in confectionery and pet care, made headlines with its $35.9 billion acquisition of Kellanova, the company behind major brands like Pringles and Cheez-It. The deal aimed to diversify Mars’s product portfolio and enhance its competitive edge in the snack food sector. Legally, this acquisition prompted discussions regarding competition law, particularly under the Clayton Act, which prohibits transactions that may substantially lessen competition. The European Commission and the U.S. FTC reviewed the deal’s potential to create a monopoly in the snack industry. Intellectual property law considerations were pivotal as Mars sought to integrate Kellanova’s extensive brand portfolio into its existing framework. Given the global nature of this transaction, compliance with varying international legal standards added layers of complexity to the merger process.

Capital One’s Acquisition of Discover Financial Services ($35.3 Billion)

One of the most pivotal financial sector transactions of 2024 was Capital One’s $35.3 billion all-stock acquisition of Discover Financial Services. This merger aimed to create an economic powerhouse capable of rivalling Visa and Mastercard by expanding Capital One’s credit card and banking footprint. Antitrust and consumer protection laws took centre stage in regulatory discussions surrounding this deal. The merger raised concerns over market concentration, with lawmakers questioning whether Capital One’s enhanced market share would lead to decreased competition and consumer harm. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) also examined potential implications for data privacy, given the consolidation of vast amounts of consumer financial data. Pending regulatory approval, the deal remains a bellwether for how financial sector M&As will be evaluated in an era of increasing data security concerns.

Synopsys’s Merger with Ansys ($35 Billion)

The technology sector saw a landmark deal with Synopsys’s agreement to merge with Ansys in a $35 billion cash-and-stock transaction. This merger combined two major players in electronic design automation and engineering simulation software, with significant implications for intellectual property and market dynamics. From a legal perspective, the deal faced immediate scrutiny under both U.S. and European Union (EU) antitrust regulations. The United Kingdom’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) initiated an investigation to assess whether the merger would stifle competition in the high-tech sector. Additionally, the merger raised concerns under patent law, as both companies hold extensive intellectual property portfolios crucial to semiconductor and engineering software innovation. Given the increasing focus on regulating Big Tech, the outcome of this transaction may set precedents for future software sector consolidations.

Hewlett Packard Enterprise’s Acquisition of Juniper Networks ($14 Billion)

Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE) made a significant strategic move with its $14 billion acquisition of Juniper Networks, targeting advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) and cloud computing. The deal aimed to strengthen HPE’s networking capabilities and enhance its enterprise IT solutions. The primary legal concern in this acquisition centred on national security considerations. Given the increasing geopolitical tensions surrounding AI and cloud technologies, the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) conducted an in-depth review to ensure the merger did not pose cybersecurity risks. Additionally, concerns over potential vendor lock-in and data access restrictions prompted discussions on fair competition and interoperability standards. This case illustrates the growing intersection of corporate M&A strategies and national security policies in the digital economy.

Broader Implications for the Legal Landscape

The five major M&A transactions of 2024 highlight several overarching legal and economic trends. First is antitrust scrutiny. With the resurgence of large-scale mergers, regulators have intensified their focus on preventing market monopolization, particularly in industries with high consumer impact, such as energy, finance, and technology. Second, data privacy and security – as companies consolidate vast amounts of consumer data, legal frameworks around cybersecurity, personal data protection, and cross-border data transfers are becoming increasingly relevant. Third, environmental and ESG considerations – mergers in industries with significant environmental footprints face growing legal challenges related to sustainability commitments and regulatory compliance. Fourth, global regulatory complexity –the international nature of these transactions necessitates compliance with varying legal standards across jurisdictions, complicating deal execution and post-merger integration. And fifth, national security and geopolitical concerns – mergers involving critical technologies, such as AI and cloud computing, are now subject to heightened national security scrutiny, reflecting broader geopolitical tensions.

The M&A boom of 2024 serves as a pivotal moment for corporate law, illustrating the evolving regulatory and legal challenges that accompany large-scale transactions. As governments and regulatory agencies intensify their oversight, companies engaging in M&A must navigate a complex web of antitrust, consumer protection, intellectual property, and national security laws. The legal precedents set by these deals will likely influence corporate strategy and regulatory frameworks for years to come, shaping the future of global business transactions.

Image by Tuxyso via WikimediaCommons